BHP trying to avoid responsibility over Brazilian dam collapse, UK court told
Mariana tailings dam collapse killed 19 people
BHP cynically trying to avoid responsibility, claimants say
Miner says London lawsuit should be dismissed
High Court hearing to last up to 12 weeks
Recasts with quotes from the start of the trial
By Sam Tobin
LONDON, Oct 21 (Reuters) -BHP BHP.AX is cynically trying to avoid its responsibility for Brazil's worst environmental disaster, lawyers representing thousands of victims told London's High Court on Monday, as a lawsuit worth up to 36 billion pounds ($47 billion) began.
More than 600,000 Brazilians, 46 local governments and around 2,000 businesses are suing BHP over the 2015 collapse of the Mariana dam in southeastern Brazil, which was owned and operated by BHP and Vale's VALE3.SA Samarco joint venture.
The dam's collapse unleashed a wave of toxic sludge that killed 19 people, left thousands homeless, flooded forests and polluted the length of the Doce River.
BHP, the world's biggest miner by market value, is contesting liability and says the London lawsuit duplicates legal proceedings and reparation and repair programmes in Brazil and should be thrown out.
It also says nearly $8 billion has already been paid to those affected through the Renova Foundation, with around $1.7 billion going to claimants involved in the English case.
The lawsuit, one of the largest in English legal history, entered a decisive stage on Monday with the beginning of a 12-week trial to determine whether BHP is liable.
The claimants' lawyer Alain Choo Choy said in court filings made public on Monday that "there is a chasm between what BHP regards as 'acceptable' and the compensation to which the claimants consider themselves legally and morally entitled".
He argued that BHP's actions in fighting the case and funding separate litigation in Brazil showed the miner was "cynically and doggedly trying to avoid" responsibility.
"Although that is BHP's choice, it cannot properly now claim to be a company 'doing the right thing' by the victims of the disaster," Choo Choy added.
'EXAGGERATED'
BHP argues it did not own or operate the dam, which held minings waste known as tailings. It said a Brazilian subsidiary of its Australian holding company was a 50% shareholder in Samarco, which operated independently.
The miner also said it had no knowledge the dam's stability was compromised before it collapsed.
Lawyers representing the miner said in court filings: "There is no law or contract which imposed any duty of safety on the ultimate parent company of a non-controlling shareholder and the other parent company in the same corporate group.
"Nor was there any breach of such duty of safety. And nor did BHP's acts or omissions cause the collapse."
BHP also said that parts of the lawsuit were "implausible or exaggerated".
Monday's hearing follows developments in BHP's negotiations with the Brazilian authorities over the disaster. The Brazilian government is discussing a nearly $30 billion compensation deal with BHP, Vale and Samarco, they said on Friday.
Tom Goodhead, CEO of Pogust Goodhead, the law firm representing the claimants, told reporters that the victims of the disaster were not involved in the planned deal.
"People just feel it's too little, too late," he said outside the High Court. "They want to go ahead with the trial, hold them accountable."
BHP said in a statement that it is trying to "finalise a fair and comprehensive compensation and rehabilitation process".
The 12-week hearing will also consider whether the Brazilian municipalities are permitted to bring legal action, the impact of any agreements reached with BHP by claimants involved in the English lawsuit and whether the claims were brought too late.
Reporting by Sam Tobin
Editing by Mark Potter and Barbara Lewis
免责声明: XM Group仅提供在线交易平台的执行服务和访问权限，并允许个人查看和/或使用网站或网站所提供的内容，但无意进行任何更改或扩展，也不会更改或扩展其服务和访问权限。所有访问和使用权限，将受下列条款与条例约束：(i) 条款与条例；(ii) 风险提示；以及(iii) 完整免责声明。请注意，网站所提供的所有讯息，仅限一般资讯用途。此外，XM所有在线交易平台的内容并不构成，也不能被用于任何未经授权的金融市场交易邀约和/或邀请。金融市场交易对于您的投资资本含有重大风险。
所有在线交易平台所发布的资料，仅适用于教育/资讯类用途，不包含也不应被视为用于金融、投资税或交易相关咨询和建议，或是交易价格纪录，或是任何金融商品或非应邀途径的金融相关优惠的交易邀约或邀请。
本网站上由XM和第三方供应商所提供的所有内容，包括意见、新闻、研究、分析、价格、其他资讯和第三方网站链接，皆保持不变，并作为一般市场评论所提供，而非投资性建议。所有在线交易平台所发布的资料，仅适用于教育/资讯类用途，不包含也不应被视为适用于金融、投资税或交易相关咨询和建议，或是交易价格纪录，或是任何金融商品或非应邀途径的金融相关优惠的交易邀约或邀请。请确保您已阅读并完全理解，XM非独立投资研究提示和风险提示相关资讯，更多详情请点击 这里。
